Home  ›  Is It Wrong for a Hindu to Eat Beef

Is It Wrong for a Hindu to Eat Beef

Written By domingo, 12 de junho de 2022 Add Comment Edit

Diet in Hinduism

Diet in Hinduism varies with its diverse traditions.

The main staples of Hindu diet include grains such as rice, wheat and millet, a multitude of legumes such as mung or chickpeas, dairy products obtained from cows and water buffalo, a variety of spices, and vegetables, many of them region specific. Some Hindus on their "fasting days" refrain from most of the daily staples but can consume a number of root vegetables such as sweet potatoes, and dairy products.

Diet in Hindu scriptures and texts [edit]

The Vedas [edit]

A goat being slaughtered at Kali Puja, painting by an Indian artist. Dated between 1800 and 1899. Inscription on verso: "A Hindoo sacrifice"

The priests anointing the buffalo as a ritual before its sacrifice at Kalibari Temple, Silchar, Assam in 2013

A man carrying the sacrificed buffalo's head in plate at Silchar in Assam

Based on writings in the Rig Veda, meat eating was prevalent since the Vedic age (1700 BCE). Pigs, boar, deer, bovines and peacocks were part of the diet. Chicken was not very desirable, even though chicken originated in India.[ better source needed ]

The Vedic texts have verses that scholars have interpreted to either mean support or opposition to meat-based food.[2] Marvin Harris mentioned, from ancient times, vegetarianism became a well-accepted mainstream Hindu tradition.[2] [3] But according to journalist Mrinal Pande, the Vedas mention around 250 animals, about 50 of which were regarded suitable for sacrifice and, by extension, for food. Gogataka (cattle), arabika (sheep), shookarika (swine), nagarika (deer), and shakuntika (fowl) were among the meats sold in the marketplace. She further adds that the Rigveda describes horses, buffaloes, rams and goats as sacrificial animals. The 162nd hymn of the Rigveda describes the elaborate horse sacrifice performed by emperors. There were even special vendors dedicated to the sale of alligator and tortoise meat (giddabuddaka). It is stated that different Vedic gods have diverse tastes in animal meat. Thus, Agni prefers bulls and barren cows, Rudra prefers red cows, and Vishnu prefers white cows.[4] [ better source needed ]

No strict dietary laws have been mentioned in Vedas,but Hindu dietary laws were made,when the Dharma sutras were being written.[5] Beef was not forbidden in the Vedas,and the sacrificial animals which were often cows which were often eaten by the Brahmins.[5] Tenth mandala of the Rigveda mentions cows being slaughtered in honour of Indra and other deities.It also mentions butcher houses that were erected to slaughter cows. Further Yajurveda mentions Ashvamedha or the horse sacrifice,[6] and even Purushamedha or the Human sacrifice (Yajurveda (VS 30–31)).The flesh of the sacrificial animals was partaken by the sacrificer. Eating of sacrificial human was later abandoned by the Brahmins, at the cost of logic inconsistency.[7] The custom of animal sacrifice still continues today throughout India.[7]

Aitareya Brahmana of the Rigveda, mentions the rules for distribution of the different parts of the sacrificial animals among the priest.[8]

... two jawbones with the tongue are to be given to the Prastotar, the breast in the form of an eagle to the Udgatar,the throat with the palate to the Pratihartar... [8]

Further it again mentions that a Kshatriya sacrificer is not allowed to eat sacrificial food (sacrificed animals and other food items), but the Brahma priest eats his portion for him.[8]

The Rig Veda (10.87.16-19) speaks about the flesh of the cattle and the horses:[9] [ better source needed ] In therapeutic section of Charak Samhita (pages 86–87) the flesh of cow is prescribed as a medicine for various diseases. It is also prescribed for making soup. It is emphatically advised as a cure for irregular fever, consumption, and emaciation. The fat of the cow is recommended for debility and rheumatism. [10]

The fiend who smears himself with flesh of cattle, with flesh of horses and of human bodies,
Who steals the milch-cow's milk away, O Agni,—tear off the heads of such with fiery fury.

The cow gives milk each year, O Man-regarder let not the Yātudhāna ever taste it.
If one would glut him with the biesting, Agni, pierce with thy flame his vitals as he meets thee.

Let the fiends drink the poison of the cattle; may Aditi cast off the evildoers.
May the God Savitar give them up to ruin, and be their share of plants and herbs denied them.

Agni, from days of old thou slayest demons never shall Rākṣasas in fight o'ercome thee.
Burn up the foolish ones, the flesh-devourers let none of them escape thine heavenly arrow.

Most consider this as a disapproval of the cow slaughter and meat eating in general.[11] Others put it in the context of demons and evil spirits (Yātudhāna) stealing the cattle and the milk. Though alternative translations by Swami Dayananda Saraswati reject such claims and give the 'correct' interpretations and translations in the light of the Brahmanas and Vedangas. According to Dayananda and Yaska, the author of Nirukta (Vedic Philology), Yātudhāna means Cattle-eaters (Yātu - Cattle / flesh of Cattle + Udhāna - eaters/ consumers).[12] [13] [14]

Bhaduri points that it was customary for cows to be offered to priests in the Vedic age and beef was a compulsory offering. He also pointed out that the Rigveda mentions that Indra asks to be served 15 to 20 cooked oxen. He pointed to the vedic text Shatapatha Brahmana, where Yajnavalkya, an ancient philosopher, said, that he'd eat it (beef) only if it is cooked till it is tender'.[15] D. N. Jha, in his book The Myth of the Holy Cow proved that cow formed part of the diet in ancient India. Quoting from the Vedas and the Upanishads, he proved that cattle were offered in sacrifice to various deities and that hardly any prayer was complete without animal sacrifice. He pointed out that during Ram's exile, Sita asked her husband for meat. And Ram obliged by getting her deer meat.[16] Maneka Gandhi points out that in context, and consistent with other Vedic verses and the Monier-Williams Sanskrit-English Dictionary, the verses have been mistranslated.[17] Edwin Bryant points out that although multiple references to animal sacrifice and consumption of animal flesh is found in the Vedas, these acts were not fully accepted as there were signs of unease and tension owing to the 'gory brutality of sacrificial butchery' dating back to as early as the older Vedas.[18] The concept of ahimsa (non-injury to living beings) is first observed as an ethical concept in the Vedas that found expression as a central tenet in Hindu texts concerned with spiritual and philosophical topics.[19]

Upanishads, Samhitas and Sutras [edit]

The Upanishads form the basis for Vedanta, which is considered the culmination of the Vedas and the philosophical paradigm of Hinduism,[20] and support the abstention from injuring living beings, proposing ahimsa as a necessity for salvation or enlightenment (Chandogya Upanishad 8.15).[21]

A hundred bulls were sacrificed by the sage Agastya, according to the Taittireeya Upanishad. the Grammarian Pāṇini devised a new term called goghna (cow slaying) to honour the guests. Much of the meat was grilled on spits or boiled in vats. Meat cooked with rice is mentioned in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad. Rama, Lakshmana, and Sita are reported to have eaten such rice with meat and vegetables during their stay in the Dandakaranya forest in the Ramayana.[4]

The Upanishads and Sutra texts of Hinduism discuss moderate diet and proper nutrition,[22] as well as Aharatattva (dietetics).[23] The Upanishads and Sutra texts invoke the concept of virtuous self-restraint in matters of food, while the Samhitas discuss what and when certain foods are suitable. A few Hindu texts such as Hathayoga Pradipika combine both.[24]

Moderation in diet is called Mitahara, and this is discussed in Shandilya Upanishad,[25] as well as by Svātmārāma as a virtue.[22] [26] [27] It is one of the yamas (virtuous self restraints) discussed in ancient Indian texts.[note 1]

Some of the earliest ideas behind Mitahara trace to ancient era Taittiriya Upanishad, which in various hymns discusses the importance of food to healthy living, to the cycle of life,[29] as well as to its role in one's body and its effect on Self (Atman, Spirit).[30] The Upanishad, states Stiles,[31] notes "from food life springs forth, by food it is sustained, and in food it merges when life departs".

Verses 1.57 through 1.63 of the Hathayoga Pradipika suggests that taste cravings should not drive one's eating habits, rather the best diet is one that is tasty, nutritious and likable as well as sufficient to meet the needs of one's body and for one's inner self.[32] It recommends that one must "eat only when one feels hungry" and "neither overeat nor eat to completely fill the capacity of one's stomach; rather leave a quarter portion empty and fill three quarters with quality food and fresh water".[32] Verses 1.59 to 1.61 of Hathayoga Pradipika suggest a mitahara regimen of a yogi avoids foods with excessive amounts of sour, salt, bitterness, oil, spice burn, unripe vegetables, fermented foods or alcohol. The practice of Mitahara, in Hathayoga Pradipika, includes avoiding stale, impure and tamasic foods, and consuming moderate amounts of fresh, vital and sattvic foods.[33]

Baudhayana says (Baudhayana Dharmasutra), carnivorous animals, tamed birds, pigs, and cocks should not be eaten. Five-toed animals, animals with cloven hoofs, birds that feed scratching with their feet, etc. may be eaten. Apastamba (Apastamba Dharmasutra) gives another list of animals not to be eaten. He also mentioned that during Shraddha, meat should be offered to the ancestors.[34]

Ramayana and Mahabharata [edit]

In the epic Ramayana, Rama, Lakshmana and Sita have been mentioned to have eaten a vast menu of diet that contained fruits, leafy vegetables, rice and meat. While being exiled at Dandakaranya, Rama and Lakshmana had hunted animals for food. Sita's favourite food was Mamsabhutadana, which is rice cooked with venison (deer meat), vegetables and spices.

Epic Mahabharata has a graphic description of cooking at a picnic, large pieces of meat were roasted on spits, cooked with tamarind, pomegranates, spices, ghee and fragrant leaves. Mahabharata mentions King Yudhisthira of feeding 10,000 Brahmins with pork and venison (deer meat).[35]

Many ancient and medieval Hindu texts debate the rationale for a voluntary stop to cow slaughter and the pursuit of vegetarianism as a part of a general abstention from violence against others and all killing of animals.[36] [37] Some significant debates between pro-non-vegetarianism and pro-vegetarianism, with mention of cattle meat as food, is found in several books of the Hindu epic, the Mahabharata, particularly its Book III, XII, XIII and XIV.[36] It is also found in the Ramayana.[37] These two epics are not only literary classics, but they have also been popular religious classics.[38] Mahabharata there is a mention of a king named Rantideva who achieved great fame by distributing foodgrains and beef to Brahmins. Taittiriya Brahman categorically tells us: `Verily the cow is food' (atho annam via gauh) and Yajnavalkya's insistence on eating the tender (amsala) flesh of the cow is well known. Even later Brahminical texts provide the evidence for eating beef. Even Manusmriti did not prohibit the consumption of beef.[10]

The Bhagavad Gita includes verses on diet and moderation in food in Chapter 6. It states in verse 6.16 that a Yogi must neither eat too much nor too little, neither sleep too much nor too little.[39] Understanding and regulating one's established habits about eating, sleeping and recreation is suggested as essential to the practice of yoga in verse 6.17.[39] [40]

Tirukkuṛaḷ [edit]

Another ancient Indian text, the Tirukkuṛaḷ, originally written in the South Indian language of Tamil, states moderate diet as a virtuous lifestyle and criticizes "non-vegetarianism" in its Pulaan Maruthal (abstinence from flesh or meat) chapter, through verses 251 through 260.[41] Verse 251, for instance, questions "how can one be possessed of kindness, who, to increase his own flesh, eats the flesh of other creatures." It also says that "the wise, who are devoid of mental delusions, do not eat the severed body of other creatures" (verse 258), suggesting that "flesh is nothing but the despicable wound of a mangled body" (verse 257). It continues to say that not eating meat is a practice more sacred than the most sacred religious practices ever known (verse 259) and that only those who refrain from killing and eating the kill are worthy of veneration (verse 260). This text, written before 400 CE, and sometimes called the Tamil Veda, discusses eating habits and its role in a healthy life (Mitahara), dedicating Chapter 95 of Book II to it.[42] The Tirukkuṛaḷ states in verses 943 through 945, "eat in moderation, when you feel hungry, foods that are agreeable to your body, refraining from foods that your body finds disagreeable". Tiruvalluvar also emphasizes overeating has ill effects on health, in verse 946, as "the pleasures of health abide in the man who eats moderately. The pains of disease dwell with him who eats excessively."[42] [43]

Dharmaśāstras [edit]

According to Kane, one who is about to eat food should greet the food when it is served to him, should honour it, never speak ill, and never find fault in it.[44] [45]

The Dharmasastra literature, states Patrick Olivelle, admonishes "people not to cook for themselves alone", offer it to the gods, to forefathers, to fellow human beings as hospitality and as alms to the monks and needy.[44] Olivelle claims all living beings are interdependent in matters of food and thus food must be respected, worshipped and taken with care.[44] Olivelle states that the Shastras recommend that when a person sees food, he should fold his hands, bow to it, and say a prayer of thanks.[44] This reverence for food reaches a state of extreme in the renouncer or monk traditions in Hinduism.[44] The Hindu tradition views procurement and preparation of food as necessarily a violent process, where other life forms and nature are disturbed, in part destroyed, changed and reformulated into something edible and palatable. The mendicants (sannyasin, ascetics) avoid being the initiator of this process, and therefore depend entirely on begging for food that is left over of householders.[44] In pursuit of their spiritual beliefs, states Olivelle, the "mendicants eat other people's left overs".[44] If they cannot find left overs, they seek fallen fruit or seeds left in field after harvest.[44]

The forest hermits of Hinduism, on the other hand, do not even beg for left overs.[44] Their food is wild and uncultivated. Their diet would consist mainly of fruits, roots, leaves, and anything that grows naturally in the forest.[44] They avoided stepping on plowed land, lest they hurt a seedling. They attempted to live a life that minimizes, preferably eliminates, the possibility of harm to any life form.[44]

Manusmriti [edit]

The Manusmriti discusses diet in chapter 5, where like other Hindu texts, it includes verses that strongly discourage meat eating, as well as verses where meat eating is declared appropriate in times of adversity and various circumstances, recommending that the meat in such circumstances be produced with minimal harm and suffering to the animal.[46] The verses 5.48-5.52 of Manusmriti explain the reason for avoiding meat as follows (abridged),

One can never obtain meat without causing injury to living beings... he should, therefore, abstain from meat. Reflecting on how meat is obtained and on how embodied creatures are tied up and killed, he should quit eating any kind of meat... The man who authorizes, the man who butchers, the man who slaughters, the man who buys or sells, the man who cooks, the man who serves, and the man who eats – these are all killers. There is no greater sinner than a man who, outside of an offering to gods or ancestors, wants to make his own flesh thrive at the expense of someone else's.

In contrast, verse 5.33 of Manusmriti states that a man may eat meat in a time of adversity, verse 5.27 recommends that eating meat is okay if not eating meat may place a person's health and life at risk, while various verses such as 5.31 and 5.39 recommend that the meat be produced as a sacrifice.[46] In verses 3.267 to 3.272, Manusmriti approves of fish and meats of deer, antelope, poultry, goat, sheep, rabbit and others as part of sacrificial food. However, Manusmriti is a law book not a spritiual book. So it permits to eat meat but it doesn't promote.[47] In an exegetical analysis of Manusmriti, Patrick Olivelle states that the document shows opposing views on eating meat was common among ancient Hindus, and that underlying emerging thought on appropriate diet was driven by ethic of non-injury and spiritual thoughts about all life forms, the trend being to reduce the consumption of meat and favour a non-injurious vegetarian lifestyle.[48]

Ayurveda [edit]

Charaka Samhita and Sushruta Samhita – two major ancient Hindu texts on health-related subjects, include many chapters on the role of diet and personal needs of an individual. In Chapter 10 of Sushruta Samhita, for example, the diet and nutrition for pregnant women, nursing mothers, and young children are described.[49] It recommends milk, butter, fluid foods, fruits, vegetables and fibrous diets for expecting mothers along with soups made from jangala (wild) meat.[50] For those recovering from injuries, growing children, those who do high levels of physical exercise, and expecting mothers, Sutrasthanam's Chapter 20 and other texts recommend carefully prepared meat. Sushruta Samhita also recommends a rotation and balance in foods consumed, in moderation.[49] For this purposes, it classifies foods by various characteristics, such as taste. In Chapter 42 of Sutrasthanam, for example, it lists six tastes – madhura (sweet), amla (acidic), lavana (salty), katuka (pungent), tikta (bitter) and kashaya (astringent). It then lists various sources of foods that deliver these tastes and recommends that all six tastes (flavors) be consumed in moderation and routinely, as a habit for good health.[51]

Meat diet [edit]

Butter chicken, one of many meat preparations found in the Indian subcontinent. Chicken is one of the primary source of meat protein among Hindus.

Kerala style Beef curry served with onions

A majority of Indian Hindus eat eggs, fish, chicken and meat.[52] According to an estimate on diaspora Hindus, about 90% of Hindus in Suriname and more than ninety five percent of Hindus in Guyana have meat-based diet.[53]

Beef was an integral food of all Indians including Brahmans in pre-Buddhist India.[54] [55] [56] In the modern-day India, Hindu communities such as Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Class eat beef. These groups of Hindus are historical beef eaters and do not believe that cow is a sacred animal.[54] In modern-day India population consisting of Dalits include beef in their diets.[57] [58] [59]

Beef is a high-protein food that millions of Scheduled Caste Hindus can afford. Beef contains 21% protein in comparison to less than 10% protein available in vegetable-based diet. This was the major reason poor Hindus continued to eat beef.[54] [59]

The Eurasian wild boar was domesticated 7,000 years ago in Asia. According to food historian K. T. Achaya, the "Kshatriya rulers were always partial to pork".[35]

The historical text Manasollasa of the Chalukya king Someshvara III (1127–1138 CE) portrayed meat as "one of the most crucial aspects of bhoga — the king's enjoyment of the luxuries of his court". It described more than 100 meat dishes including blood sausages, goat heads, barbecued river rats, and grilled stomach membrane. Game birds, venison, and pork are considered delicacies in Manasollasa. Recipes of meat included cooking on skewers, curried, grilled, fried in ghee. Meat recipes that are similar to kebabs were mentioned several centuries before the arrival of Muslim-rulers in India. According to the Manasollasa, prescribed five-course meals for kings meat was to be eaten in at least three of the five meals.[60]

Tamil writings between 100 BCE and 300 CE mention that Tamil people ate all kind of meals including fish. Perumpanooru mentions that Tamils of the Sangam period enjoyed beef dishes. Around 700 CE, immigrants entered the region of modern-day Tamil Nadu, after which the practice of vegetarianism started to be followed by some.

Brahmins, few Vaishnavite sects in India and Saivite non-Brahmins of South India avoid meat diet. Brahmins of East India, Kashmir and the Saraswats of the Southwest are allowed to eat fish and some meat.

Poultry, fish and other seafood, goat, and sheep are the popular meat diets of Hindus in modern age.[61] In Eastern and coastal south-western regions of India, fish and seafood is the staple of most of the local communities.

The Aghori sect of the Hindu holy men across India, consume meat and alcohol. They also feed on human flesh of corpse.[62]

In Maharashtra region, the Mahar community under the Balutedar system was assigned the work of disposing off dead cattle caracasses from the village. The community treated the dead animal as a source of meat which resulted in the caste being treated as untouchables.[63] Most members of Mahar community have now embraced Buddhism. The dalit caste of Musahar from Bihar and Nepal include rat meat in their diet.[64]

Festivals [edit]

Festival of Holi is celebrated with dishes of Chicken and mutton.[a] [65] [66] The prices of meat soar during Holi due to the high demand. Mutton curry prepared in spices, mustard oil and ghee is a popular dish in Holi.[67] [68] In Karnataka, Holi celebration on the day of Dhulwad, involves eating mutton bondas, large meat and potato balls.[69]

Dassera (Navratri) festival is celebrated in Gujarat with feasts of mutton and wine.[70] Magh festival celebrated in January begins with sacrifice of goat and pig.[71] [72] [73] Sheep and chicken are also killed during Magh.[74] The sacrificed animal is then cooked and served during feast.[75]

Shivratri festival is celebrated with dishes of mutton, fish and chicken. Mutton and fish are offered as prasada.[76] Goats and sheep are sacrificed to Shiva and Devi, and the mutton is distributed among the neighbors and relatives and consumed.[77] [78] In Kashmir, the prasada for Shivratri puja consisted of a pile of rice, cooked lamb and fish, with an entire raw fish added to the top of the pile.[79]

In Himachal Pradesh, all festivals involve mandatory preparation of meat dishes, especially in the festival of Dussehra, Shivratri and 'Magh ka saja'.[80]

Some Hindus abstain from eating meat diet during days of fasting in festivals like Navratri, and Diwali, etc.[81] [82] but for many other Hindu communities offering of meat (prasad) is an essential ritual of celebrating these festivals.[83] [84] [85] [86]

Vegetarian diet [edit]

A lacto-vegetarian thali from Western Indian state of Maharashtra

A vegetarian plate from Andhra

A fasting day lunch in Maharashtra prepared during the festival of Aashadhi Ekadashi

Hinduism does not require a vegetarian diet,[87] but some Hindus avoid eating meat because it minimizes hurting other life forms.[88] As of 2021, 44% of Hindus living in India report adhering to some type of vegetarian diet.[82] Vegetarianism is considered satvic, that is purifying the body and mind lifestyle in some Hindu texts.[89] [90]

Lacto-vegetarianism and Vegetarianism are one of the four tenets of ISKCON.[91] The agenda of faith-based organizations and Hindutva groups is imposing vegetarianism on their followers.[92]

Indians who follow a Vegetarian diet in India on the basis of their religious faith, consider meat and eggs as polluted. They neither eat at places with different dietary practices nor share their meal with them. Religious groups Brahmins, Lingayats, and Jains are lacto-vegetarian groups and claim that consuming egg hurts their sentiments.[92]

Some sects of Hindus prefer a vegetarian or lacto-vegetarian lifestyle, and methods of food production that are in harmony with nature, compassionate, and respectful of other life forms as well as nature.[93]

Lacto-vegetarianism is favored by some Hindus, which includes milk-based foods and all other non-animal derived foods, but it excludes meat and eggs.[94] There are three main reasons for this: the principle of nonviolence (ahimsa) applied to animals,[95] the intention to offer only vegetarian food to their preferred deity and then to receive it back as prasad, and the conviction that non-vegetarian food is detrimental for the mind and for spiritual development.[89] [96] Many Hindus point to scriptural bases, such as the Mahabharata's maxim that "Nonviolence is the highest duty and the highest teaching",[97] as advocating a vegetarian diet. In contrast with the western world, many Hindu's in India do not consider ovo-lacto-vegetarian diets to be a "pure vegetarian" diet because they do not consider eggs to be truly vegetarian. For this reason, many Hindu vegetarians use the neologism "eggetarian" to identify otherwise vegetarian diets that incorporate eggs.[98] [99]

A typical modern urban Hindu lacto-vegetarian meal is based on a combination of grains such as rice and wheat, legumes, green vegetables, and dairy products.[100] Depending on the geographical region the staples may include millet-based flatbreads. Fat derived from slaughtered animals is avoided.[101]

A number of Hindus, particularly those following the Vaishnav tradition, refrain from eating onions and garlic during Chaturmas period (roughly July - November of Gregorian calendar).[102] In Maharashtra, a number of Hindu families also do not eat any egg plant (Brinjal / Aubergine) preparations during this period.[103]

The followers of ISKCON (International Society for Krishna Consciousness, Hare Krishna) abstain from meat, fish, and fowl. The related Pushtimargi sect followers also avoid certain vegetables such as onion, mushrooms and garlic, out of the belief that these are tamas (harmful).[101] [104] Swaminarayan movement members staunchly adhere to a diet that is devoid of meat, eggs, and seafood.[105]

Some Hindu groups such as the Marathi speaking people in Tamil Nadu, observe fasting during the festivals and only eat certain kinds of foods.[106] These include milk and other dairy products such as dahi, fruit and starchy Western food items such as sago,[107] potatoes,[108] purple-red sweet potatoes, amaranth seeds.[109]

See also [edit]

  • Buddhist cuisine
  • Buddhist vegetarianism
  • Christian dietary laws
  • Diet in Sikhism
  • Etiquette of Indian dining
  • Indian vegetarian cuisine
  • Islamic dietary laws
  • Kashrut (Jewish Dietary Laws)
  • List of diets
  • Vegetarian cuisine
  • Vegetarian Diet Pyramid
  • Vegetarianism and religion

Note [edit]

  1. ^ Reliable sources discussing meat dishes in Holi
    • "Holi Recipes: Holi 2022: 10 traditional Holi recipes that will take you back to childhood!". The Times of India. 17 March 2022. For non-vegetarians, Holi means spicy mutton curry loaded with spices and aroma,
    • "Holi 2022 crowd gathered to buy chicken muton in maharashtra". V Nation. 18 March 2022. Retrieved 4 June 2022. महाराष्ट्र में होली के दिन सिर्फ मटन ही खरीद कर खाया जाता है (On the day of Holi in Maharashtra, only mutton is purchased and cooked.)
    • "Holi में यहां सात हजार क्विंटल मटन डकार जायेंगे लोग, जान‍िए क‍ितने च‍िकन और फ‍िश की होगी खपत". NEWSWING . Retrieved 4 June 2022.
  1. ^ The other nine yamas are Ahinsā (अहिंसा): Nonviolence, Satya (सत्य): truthfulness, Asteya (अस्तेय): not stealing, Brahmacharya (ब्रह्मचर्य): celibacy and not cheating on one's spouse, Kṣhamā (क्षमा): forgiveness,[28] Dhṛti (धृति): fortitude, Dayā (दया): compassion,[28] Ārjava (आर्जव): sincerity, non-hypocrisy, and Śauca (शौच): purity, cleanliness.

References [edit]

  1. ^ a b Marvin Harris (1990), India's sacred cow, Anthropology: contemporary perspectives, 6th edition, Editors: Phillip Whitten & David Hunter, Scott Foresman, ISBN 0-673-52074-9, pages 201-204
  2. ^ Lisa Kemmerer (2011). Animals and World Religions. Oxford University Press. pp. 59–68 (Hinduism), pp. 100–110 (Buddhism). ISBN978-0-19-979076-0.
  3. ^ a b "From Ramayana to the scriptures, it's clear India has a long history of eating meat".
  4. ^ a b Sagar, Sunder Lal (1975). "Food and caste system (Pages:49-64)". Hindu culture and caste system in India. Uppal Book Store. pp. 234 pages.
  5. ^ Kashyap, Rangasami Laksminarayana (2003). Kr̥ṣṇayajurvedīya Taittirīya-saṃhitā (in English and Sanskrit). Sri Aurobindo Kapāli Sāstry Institute of Vedic Culture. p. 766. ISBN9788179940051.
  6. ^ a b E Ragozin, Zanaide. History of Vedic India. Mittal Publications.
  7. ^ a b c Martin Haug, ed. (1863). The Aitareya Brahmanam of the Rigveda: containing the earliest speculations of the Brahmans on the meaning of the sacrificial prayers, and on the orig., performance and sense of the rites of the Vedic religion. Vol. 2. Government Central Book Dep©ot. p. 537.
  8. ^ "Rig Veda: Rig-Veda, Book 10: HYMN LXXXVII. Agni".
  9. ^ a b "Archive News". The Hindu.
  10. ^ Editors of Hinduism Today (15 April 2007). What Is Hinduism?: Modern Adventures Into a Profound Global Faith. Himalayan Academy Publications. p. 346. ISBN978-1-934145-27-2 . Retrieved 12 February 2013.
  11. ^ "Rigveda Bhashya Vol 5".
  12. ^ Raj Pruthi (2004). 11. Vedic Civilization. Discovery Publishing House. p. 2. ISBN978-81-7141-875-6 . Retrieved 12 February 2013.
  13. ^ Sri M. P. Pandit (1 June 1990). Wisdom of the Veda. Lotus Press. p. 101. ISBN978-0-941524-55-1 . Retrieved 12 February 2013.
  14. ^ "Vedas Are Replete With Beef Eating Hindu Gods, Says India's Leading Indologist". HuffPost. 25 September 2018.
  15. ^ "Prof D.N. Jha (1940-2021), a rare historian who wore his knowledge with ease".
  16. ^ "Time to end the mischief". The Statesman. 2015-07-19. Retrieved 2020-09-21 .
  17. ^ Waldau, Paul (2006). A Communion of Subjects: Animals in Religion, Science, and Ethics. Columbia University Press. pp. 194–203 +Paul+(2006).+A+Communion+of+Subjects:+Animals+in+Religion, +Science, +and+Ethics.+Columbia+University+Press&ots=M0XLARS7iH&sig=EAEIo8Gv8Tvr8AXZRTSgZQseh70#v=onepage&q=brutality&f=false. ISBN9780231136426.
  18. ^ Sundararajan, K.R. (2003). Hindu Spirituality: Postclassical and Modern. Motilal Banarsidass Publ. pp. 393–398 +K.R.+(2003).+Hindu+Spirituality:+Postclassical+and+Modern.&ots=9N1raA30NW&sig=Vd8siGNW6CCPoi0qMX1qaQlOHAI#v=snippet&q=vegetarian%20hindu&f=false.
  19. ^ Flood, Gavin (1996). An Introduction to Hinduism. Cambridge University Press. p. 238.
  20. ^ "The Chandogya Upanishad". www.hinduwebsite.com . Retrieved 2020-09-21 .
  21. ^ a b Svātmārāma; Pancham Sinh (1997). The Hatha Yoga Pradipika (5th ed.). Forgotten Books. p. 14. ISBN9781605066370.
    Quote - अथ यम-नियमाः
    अहिंसा सत्यमस्तेयं बरह्यछर्यम कश्हमा धृतिः
    दयार्जवं मिताहारः शौछम छैव यमा दश
  22. ^ Caraka Samhita Ray and Gupta, National Institute of Sciences, India, pages 18-19
  23. ^ Hathayoga Pradipika Brahmananda, Adyar Library, The Theosophical Society, Madras India (1972)
  24. ^ KN Aiyar (1914), Thirty Minor Upanishads, Kessinger Publishing, ISBN 978-1164026419, Chapter 22, pages 173-176
  25. ^ Lorenzen, David (1972). The Kāpālikas and Kālāmukhas. University of California Press. pp. 186–190. ISBN978-0520018426.
  26. ^ Subramuniya (2003). Merging with Śiva: Hinduism's contemporary metaphysics. Himalayan Academy Publications. p. 155. ISBN9780945497998 . Retrieved 6 April 2009.
  27. ^ a b Stuart Sovatsky (1998), Words from the Soul: Time East/West Spirituality and Psychotherapeutic Narrative, State University of New York, ISBN 978-0791439494, page 21
  28. ^ Annamaya Kosa Taittiriya Upanishad, Anuvaka II, pages 397-406
  29. ^ Realization of Brahman Taittiriya Upanishad, Anuvaka II & VII, pages 740-789; This is extensively discussed in these chapters; Illustrative quote - "Life, verily, is food; the body the food-eater" (page 776)
  30. ^ M Stiles (2008), Ayurvedic Yoga Therapy, Lotus Press, ISBN 978-0940985971, pages 56-57
  31. ^ a b KS Joshi, Speaking of Yoga and Nature-Cure Therapy, Sterling Publishers, ISBN 978-1845570453, page 65-66
  32. ^ Steven Rosen (2011), Food for the Soul: Vegetarianism and Yoga Traditions, Praeger, ISBN 978-0313397035, pages 25-29
  33. ^ Iyengar, P. T. Srinivasa (2001). History of the Tamils: from the earliest times to 600 A.D. History / Asia / India & South Asia (4, reprint ed.). Asian Educational Services. pp. 635 pages. ISBN81-206-0145-9.
  34. ^ a b Verma, Rahul (25 September 2021). "Pork has hardcore fans all over the world". The Hindu . Retrieved 21 May 2022. In the Mahabharata, King Yudhisthira fed 10,000 Brahmins with pork and venison
  35. ^ a b Ludwig Alsdorf (2010). The History of Vegetarianism and Cow-Veneration in India. Routledge. pp. 32–44 with footnotes. ISBN978-1-135-16641-0.
  36. ^ a b John R. McLane (2015). Indian Nationalism and the Early Congress. Princeton University Press. pp. 271–280 with footnotes. ISBN978-1-4008-7023-3.
  37. ^ John McLaren; Harold Coward (1999). Religious Conscience, the State, and the Law: Historical Contexts and Contemporary Significance. State University of New York Press. pp. 199–204. ISBN978-0-7914-4002-5.
  38. ^ a b Paul Turner (2013), FOOD YOGA - Nourishing Body, Mind & Soul, 2nd Edition, ISBN 978-0985045111, page 164
  39. ^ Stephen Knapp, The Heart of Hinduism: The Eastern Path to Freedom, Empowerment and Illumination, ISBN 978-0595350759, page 284
  40. ^ Tirukkural, Translated by GU Pope et al., WH Allen, London, verses 251-260, pages 31-32, and pages 114-115, 159
  41. ^ a b Tirukkuṛaḷ see Chapter 95, Book 7
  42. ^ Tirukkuṛaḷ Translated by V.V.R. Aiyar, Tirupparaithurai: Sri Ramakrishna Tapovanam (1998)
  43. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Patrick Olivelle (1991). "From feast to fast: food and the Indian Ascetic". In Gerrit Jan Meulenbeld; Julia Leslie (eds.). Medical Literature from India, Sri Lanka, and Tibet. BRILL. pp. 17–36. ISBN978-9004095229.
  44. ^ Kane, History of the Dharmaśāstras Vol. 2, p. 762
  45. ^ a b c Patrick Olivelle (2005), Manu's Code of Law, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0195171464, pages 139-141
  46. ^ Patrick Olivelle (2005), Manu's Code of Law, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0195171464, page 122
  47. ^ Patrick Olivelle (2005), Manu's Code of Law, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0195171464, pages 279-280
  48. ^ a b KKL Bhishagratna, Chapter X, Sushruta Samhita, Vol 2, Calcutta, page 216-238
  49. ^ Sushruta Samhita KKL Bhishagratna, Vol 2, Calcutta, page 217
  50. ^ KKL Bhishagratna, Sutrasthanam, Chapter XLII Sushruta Samhita, Vol 1, Calcutta, page 385-393
  51. ^ CHAKRAVARTI, A.K (2007). "Cultural dimensions of diet and disease in india". City, Society, and Planning: Society. Concept Publishing Company. pp. 151–. ISBN978-81-8069-460-8.
  52. ^ "Hindus of South America".
  53. ^ a b c Ilaiah, Kancha (1996). "Beef, BJP and Food Rights of People". Economic and Political Weekly. 31 (24): 1444–1445. ISSN 0012-9976. JSTOR 4404260.
  54. ^ PATNAIK, BISWARAJ (17 December 2020). "Study shows ancient Hindus ate meat-heavy food". The Pioneer . Retrieved 4 June 2022. The findings indicate that 'Indus Valley' people were exceedingly fond of eating meat. More so, they preferred to consume beef over other meats. These findings have been reported in a new study titled 'Lipid residues in pottery from the Indus Civilisation in northwest India' published in the Journal of Archaeological Science.
  55. ^ "India highlights dark side of vegetarianism". Nikkei Asia. 12 January 2022. Retrieved 4 June 2022.
  56. ^ Ranade, Chandrashekhar G (2012). "Policy on Beef and Pork". Economic and Political Weekly. 47 (20): 4–5. ISSN 0012-9976. JSTOR 23214607.
  57. ^ PATOLE, SHAHU (10 September 2016). "Why I wrote a book on Dalit food". Express Foodie beta . Retrieved 11 September 2016.
  58. ^ a b Mangaldas, Leeza (5 June 2017). "India's Got Beef With Beef: What You Need To Know About The Country's Controversial 'Beef Ban'". Forbes . Retrieved 4 June 2022.
  59. ^ Kanisetti, Anirudh (19 May 2022). "Food fights not new to India. Medieval texts show mud-slinging among Jains, Buddhists, Hindus". ThePrint . Retrieved 21 May 2022.
  60. ^ Ridgwell and Ridgway (1987), Food Around the World, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0198327288, page 67
  61. ^ "Indian doc focuses on Hindu cannibal sect". Today. The Associated Press. October 27, 2005. Retrieved 2019-11-05 .
  62. ^ Rāmacandra Kshīrasāgara (1994). Dalit Movement in India and Its Leaders, 1857-1956. M.D. Publications. p. 33. ISBN978-81-85880-43-3.
  63. ^ Prasad, A. (2007). "The Musahars of Bihar: A Dalit Community in the Vortex of Change" (PDF). Indian Journal of Social Work. 68 (1): 152.
  64. ^ Bose, Nirmal Kumar (1967). Culture and Society in India. Asia Publishing House. p. 45. ISBN978-0-210-33830-8 . Retrieved 4 June 2022. The Maratha people of the Bombay Presidency sacrifice a goat during the Holi
  65. ^ Singh, K. S.; Lavania, B. K. (1998). Rajasthan. Popular Prakashan. p. 117. ISBN978-81-7154-766-1 . Retrieved 4 June 2022. On the day of Dhulendi (next day of Holi festival), every family sacrifices a goat at the shrine of Kali Mai. They sacrifice a goat on the ninth day of Navratra
  66. ^ "Holi 2019: 13 traditional Holi dishes from Bihar that no food lover should miss". The Times of India. 8 March 2020. Retrieved 23 May 2022. For non-vegetarians, Holi is all about mutton and chicken. If you don't believe us, visit any meat shop on the eve of Holi and the crowd and sky-rocketing prices will clear your doubts. The regional version of Mutton Curry has a lot of raw spices and is made in mustard oil and ghee.
  67. ^ "Chicken prices soar at farmgate level due to high feed costs, cut in production". Financialexpress. 12 March 2022. Retrieved 2 June 2022. every year poultry prices go up due to higher demand during March as during Holi festival
  68. ^ Pawar, Urmila (15 July 2009). The Weave of My Life: A Dalit Woman's Memoirs. Columbia University Press. ISBN978-0-231-52057-7 . Retrieved 2 June 2022.
  69. ^ Gujarat State Gazetteers: Banaskantha District. Directorate of Government Print., Stationery and Publications, Gujarat State. 1981. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
  70. ^ Thakur, D. N. Thakur D. (2009). Tribal Women. Deep & Deep Publications. ISBN978-81-8450-109-4 . Retrieved 2 June 2022.
  71. ^ Saksena, R. N. (1962). Social Economy of a Polyandrous People. Asia Publishing House. p. 90. Magh Festival: Their biggest festival is the winter festival known as Magh. The celebrations begin in the middle of January and go on till the end of February. On the first day a goat is sacrificed in every house.
  72. ^ Hasnain, Nadeem (1982). Bonded for Ever: A Study of the Kolta, a Cis-Himalayan Tribe. Harnam Publications. p. 25. Retrieved 4 June 2022. They sacrifice a goat on the first day of Magh and those who are economically weaker like the Kolta and other Harijans, sacrifice pigs. The entire month of Magh is spent in merry making.
  73. ^ Pandhe, M. K. (1977). "Social Life in Rural India". India Book Exchange. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
  74. ^ Bihar and Orissa District Gazeteers: Santal Parganas (1938). Superintendent, Government Printing. 1938. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
  75. ^ Bahadur, Om Lata (1994). The Book of Hindu Festivals and Ceremonies. UBS Publishers'. ISBN978-81-86112-23-6 . Retrieved 2 June 2022.
  76. ^ Section, Himachal Pradesh (India) Directorate of Industries Survey of Handicrafts (1969). Survey Report on Handicrafts of ... Himachal Pradesh: Kinnaur . Retrieved 4 June 2022. Goats and sheep are sacrificed to Shiva and the Devis on a Shivratri. The mutton is distributed among relatives and neighbours
  77. ^ Hāṇḍā, Omacanda (2006). Western Himalayan Folk Arts. Pentagon Press. p. 86. ISBN978-81-8274-195-9 . Retrieved 4 June 2022. They slaughter several goats on that day and the goat meat is distributed among the relatives and consumed.
  78. ^ Sudha Koul (20 May 2017). "The Meat of the Matter With Kashmiri Pandits". The Wire . Retrieved 4 June 2022.
  79. ^ India, Anthropological Survey of (1996). Himachal Pradesh. Anthropological Survey of India. p. 485. ISBN978-81-7304-094-8. During festive occasions, especially, Dussehra, Shivratri and Magh ka - saja, meat preparations are a must. In winter months, sheep or goat are slaughtered and then meat is kept by every household to be consumed daily
  80. ^ "Why Hindus do not eat Non Vegetarian Food on particular days?". WordZz. September 10, 2016.
  81. ^ a b Corichi, Manolo. "Eight-in-ten Indians limit meat in their diets, and four-in-ten consider themselves vegetarian". Pew Research Center . Retrieved 2022-01-31 .
  82. ^ "Kandhen Budhi" (PDF). Orissa.gov.in. Retrieved 18 February 2015.
  83. ^ "Bali Jatra of Sonepur" (PDF). Orissa.gov.in. Archived from the original (PDF) on 5 January 2015. Retrieved 18 February 2015.
  84. ^ (Barik, 2009:160–162).[ full citation needed ]
  85. ^ Christopher John Fuller (2004). The Camphor Flame: Popular Hinduism and Society in India. Princeton University Press. pp. 46, 83–85. ISBN978-0-691-12048-5.
  86. ^ Madhulika Khandelwal (2002), Becoming American, Being Indian, Cornell University Press, ISBN 978-0801488078, pages 38-39
  87. ^ Steven Rosen, Essential Hinduism, Praeger, ISBN 978-0275990060, page 187
  88. ^ a b N Lepes (2008), The Bhagavad Gita and Inner Transformation, Motilal Banarsidass , ISBN 978-8120831865, pages 352-353
  89. ^ Michael Keene (2002). Religion in Life and Society. Folens Limited. p. 122. ISBN978-1-84303-295-3 . Retrieved May 18, 2009.
  90. ^ Bryant, Edwin Francis; Ekstrand, Maria (2004). The Hare Krishna movement the postcharismatic fate of a religious transplant. Columbia University Press. OCLC 748865897.
  91. ^ a b Jain, Mahima (26 February 2022). "Faith vs. nutrition: India's school meals program walks on eggshells". Retrieved 20 March 2022.
  92. ^ Susan Dudek (2013), Nutrition Essentials for Nursing Practice, Wolters Kluwer Health, ISBN 978-1451186123, page 251
  93. ^ Paul Insel (2013), Discovering Nutrition, Jones & Bartlett Publishers, ISBN 978-1284021165, page 231
  94. ^ Tähtinen, Unto: Ahimsa. Non-Violence in Indian Tradition, London 1976, p. 107-109.
  95. ^ Mahabharata 12.257 (note that Mahabharata 12.257 is 12.265 according to another count); Bhagavad Gita 9.26; Bhagavata Purana 7.15.7.
  96. ^ Mahabharata 13.116.37-41
  97. ^ Robson, John R. K. (24 October 2018). Food, Ecology and Culture: Readings in the Anthropology of Dietary Practices. Routledge. ISBN9781317949732.
  98. ^ "eggetarian". Wiktionary. 25 October 2021. Retrieved 19 February 2022.
  99. ^ Sanford, A Whitney."Gandhi's agrarian legacy: practicing food, justice, and sustainability in India". Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature and Culture 7 no 1 Mr 2013, p 65-87.
  100. ^ a b Eleanor Nesbitt (2004), Intercultural Education: Ethnographic and Religious Approaches, Sussex Academic Press, ISBN 978-1845190347, pages 25-27
  101. ^ J. Gordon Melton (2011). Religious Celebrations: L-Z. ABC-CLIO. pp. 172–173. ISBN978-1-59884-205-0.
  102. ^ B. V. Bhanu (2004). People of India: Maharashtra. Popular Prakashan. p. 851. ISBN978-81-7991-101-3.
  103. ^ Narayanan, Vasudha. "The Hindu Tradition". In A Concise Introduction to World Religions, ed. Willard G. Oxtoby and Alan F. Segal. New York: Oxford University Press, 2007
  104. ^ Williams, Raymond. An Introduction to Swaminarayan Hinduism. 1st. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001. 159
  105. ^ Katona-Apte, Judith; Arnott, Margaret L. (1975). Gastronomy: Dietary aspects of acculturation: Meals, feasts, and fasts in a minority community in South Asia. Gastronomy: The Anthropology of Food and Food Habits. The Hague: Mouton. pp. 315–322. ISBN90-279-7739-9.
  106. ^ Arnott, Margaret L. (1975). Gastronomy: the anthropology of food and food habitys. The Hague: Mouton. p. 319. ISBN978-9027977397 . Retrieved 31 October 2016.
  107. ^ Walker, Harlan, ed. (1997). Food on the move: proceedings of the Oxford Symposium on Food and Cookery 1996, [held in September 1996 at Saint Antony's College, Oxford]. Devon, England: Prospect Books. p. 291. ISBN978-0-907325-79-6 . Retrieved 31 October 2016.
  108. ^ Amaranth: Modern Prospects for an Ancient Crop. National Academies. 1984. p. 6. ISBN9780309324458. NAP:14295.

Bibliography [edit]

  • Gupte, B. A. (1994). Hindu Holidays and Ceremonials: With Dissertations on Origin, Folklore and Symbols. Asian Educational Services. pp. 1–. ISBN978-81-206-0953-2.

harristhornested82.blogspot.com

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diet_in_Hinduism

0 Response to "Is It Wrong for a Hindu to Eat Beef"

Postar um comentário

Assinar: Postar comentários (Atom)

Iklan Atas Artikel

Iklan Tengah Artikel 1

Iklan Tengah Artikel 2

Iklan Bawah Artikel